Talk:Instrumental 1: Difference between revisions
From The Evanescence Reference
Haley Sands (talk | contribs) (→These tracks shouldn't be here: new section) |
Haley Sands (talk | contribs) |
||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
== These tracks shouldn't be here == | == These tracks shouldn't be here == | ||
It's probably best to remove these 4 songs from the list. The only release they've ever received is some guy on eBay who also managed to get ahold of the If You Don't Mind studio version. May I remind everybody that since these are simply instrumentals, we have NO way of identifying them as Evanescence material? If Amy was singing in any them, we could identify them as Evanescence songs by her voice, but since she isn't, there is nothing to verify that they are Ev material. I'm | It's probably best to remove these 4 songs from the list. The only release they've ever received is some guy on eBay who also managed to get ahold of the If You Don't Mind studio version. May I remind everybody that since these are simply instrumentals, we have NO way of identifying them as Evanescence material? If Amy was singing in any them, we could identify them as Evanescence songs by her voice, but since she isn't, there is nothing to verify that they are Ev material. I'm proposing they be removed unless you happen to have some proof stashed away somewhere that these tracks are original Ev songs. [[User:Haley Sands|Haley Sands]] ([[User talk:Haley Sands|talk]]) 17:22, 10 May 2013 (PDT) | ||
Latest revision as of 17:22, 10 May 2013
These tracks shouldn't be here
It's probably best to remove these 4 songs from the list. The only release they've ever received is some guy on eBay who also managed to get ahold of the If You Don't Mind studio version. May I remind everybody that since these are simply instrumentals, we have NO way of identifying them as Evanescence material? If Amy was singing in any them, we could identify them as Evanescence songs by her voice, but since she isn't, there is nothing to verify that they are Ev material. I'm proposing they be removed unless you happen to have some proof stashed away somewhere that these tracks are original Ev songs. Haley Sands (talk) 17:22, 10 May 2013 (PDT)
